Annexation feud splits N.C. town
Daniel Willis has launched a one-man crusade against the town's white
leadership
By KRISTIN COLLINS, Staff Writer
TRENTON -- People here don't like to talk about the time when the
television cameras came to town.
That was in 1999, when then-Mayor Joffree Leggett said aloud what some
blacks said they suspected for years: Trenton didn't want to annex the
black neighborhoods that border the town because it didn't want blacks
on the town board.
"That's settled," Town Commissioner
Charles Jones says. "People have forgotten it. We don't need to get back
into that."
Five years ago, under the glare of a
national spotlight, it looked as if this fading town of 200, in one of
Eastern North Carolina's poorest counties, would never be the same.
For decades, whites had outnumbered
blacks in this Jones County town -- but only because about 50 black
households sat just outside the town borders in neighborhoods known as
Haiti, Monktown and Spicey Quinn lands.
Even though the neighborhoods were laid
out on an urban grid and sat nestled up against the town limits, they
had never been part of Trenton proper. People there couldn't vote in
town elections, and no black had ever served in town government.
When people heard the mayor's comments,
the blacks at town's edge came together and vowed to fight for a voice.
Town leaders promised that the town and the neighborhoods would finally
be united.
A black mayor was appointed, and the
blacks outside town limits got an opportunity they had never had: Anyone
who asked would be annexed and get the right to vote in town elections.
Then, the television
cameras left
Of an estimated 50 properties, only 17
homeowners and two churches asked to be annexed. They joined the town in
2001.
The limited annexation kept whites in
the majority in Trenton, which had 144 whites and 55 blacks in the 2000
census.
The black mayor, Sylvia Willis, has
been re-elected twice, but she hardly speaks above a whisper in town
meetings. No blacks have run for the town board.
Whether in town or out, blacks live in
segregated neighborhoods distinguished by poverty. And many say they
still feel powerless.
"They only want a certain number of
blacks to be eligible to vote around here," says Della Ancrum, who
recently moved back to her family home that sits just outside the town
limits. "They have all the power. They make the laws. How can you fight
that?"
The old wound
Trenton pops up amid the farm fields of
rural Jones County, about 100 miles east of Raleigh, like a mirage from
the past. Its main street is lined with moss-draped oaks, and an
old-fashioned hardware store and pharmacy are its anchor businesses.
People smile and wave when they pass on the street.
But under the surface, there is a
residue of bitterness that divides races, fractures neighborhoods and
simmers within families.
Daniel Johnson Willis, the mayor's
husband, is the person credited, or blamed, for starting it all.
Willis, 70, a retired television
repairman, has led a one-man crusade against the town's white leadership
for nearly two decades. He and his wife live in town, but it irks him
that so many other blacks don't have a voice in Trenton.
It was his lawsuit in 1999 -- claiming
that the town was racist in its refusal to annex the black neighborhoods
-- that prompted Leggett to utter the words that set off the whole
fight: "They're not leaders. A black man would rather work for a white
person."
Leggett has since died.
Willis says he believed in 1999 that
Trenton would finally change.
Now, he says, nothing is different. He
blames the reporters who didn't come back. He blames the state branch of
the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People for
promising to fight alongside him and then leaving town. He blames his
wife.
"They keep her as mayor because they're
trying to show people that we're integrated," he says. "The mayor has no
voice. She never asks for anything for us."
Sylvia Willis, 64, sitting in the next
room, says she has no response to her husband's criticisms. But she
admits to feeling sometimes like an outsider in town government.
She says the town clerk padlocked the
door to the room that holds the town records before giving her a key to
town hall. Board members say it has always been locked.
The mayor says she doesn't want to open
"old wounds" by talking about the events of 1999. She refuses to say
that the town has made no progress on race relations since then.
"The few little people that were
annexed, that's progress," Sylvia Willis says. "Things don't happen
overnight. I know that there will be change, because it's written in the
book, in the Bible. It might not be in my day, but it will come."
After the cameras left
A full annexation of the neighborhoods
would have cost Trenton almost nothing, and it would have boosted a
sagging tax base.
But the town board chose to make the
annexation voluntary. Only people who signed forms requesting it were
taken in.
"The town does not force annexation on
anyone," town clerk Glenn Spivey says.
Spivey points out that for most blacks,
annexation means nothing but extra taxes. The town, which has no
employees, provides only one service: sewer. And thanks to state and
federal grants, most black neighborhoods outside town already have it.
For a few residents, most friends of
Willis, that argument wasn't enough to keep them out.
"I did it because I knew they didn't
want to annex me," says Edna Lee Hobbs, 68, whose home was annexed. "I
know they was hoping nobody would want to be annexed, and that'd be
their excuse not to do it."
After she signed her petition, Hobbs
said a sheriff's deputy came to her house. She said he demanded her name
and asked to come into her house, wanting to know whether she had signed
the petition. She thought he was trying to intimidate her.
Town board member Charles Jones said
the town clerk and another town representative did go into neighborhoods
to verify petitions. He said no sheriff's deputies were used.
Now, Hobbs lives in town. But she says
the homes all around her are outside town limits.
"Who ever heard of getting put in town
like that?" Hobbs asks.
She says she has seen two changes since
becoming an official Trenton resident: She now has a town street light,
and the town puts up Christmas decorations in her neighborhood each
winter.
A buried past
Several others who were annexed refused
to talk to a reporter, saying it would single them out for criticism.
The pastors of the two annexed churches also didn't return repeated
calls.
"People here, they are so afraid of the
white folks," says Daniel Willis, who was born and raised in Trenton.
"They have been brainwashed. They need somebody to come here and lift
their heads out of the dirt."
Willis says that's the reason most who
declined annexation also won't talk about it.
"It was just my choice," says Will
Brock, a resident of Haiti who was not annexed. "There was no biggie
about it."
Brock, who is chairman of the Jones
County Board of Elections, said the right to vote in town elections
wasn't important to him. He said he feels he has more privacy as he is.
Brock wouldn't comment on whether he
thinks racism shapes Trenton's annexation policies.
Skip Alston, president of the state
NAACP, says there is nothing more he can do in Trenton. People were
given the choice to be annexed, and many said no.
"It's not for me to say whether it's
OK," Alston says. "It's for the citizens to say whether it's OK, and
they made their choice."
What most people in this town want is
to keep the past buried.
Spivey, the town clerk, berated a
reporter who came asking for information about how many people were
annexed. He said Daniel Willis, whom he referred to as a "piece of --
nothing," is the cause of the town's problems.
"The people didn't ask for it; Mr.
Willis asked for it," Spivey said. "Mr. Willis is the one that created
the annexation issue."
Daniel Willis is discouraged, but he
will not give up. Recently, he has started going back into the black
neighborhoods, trying to persuade people who weren't annexed before to
request it now. He has a stack of signed petitions that he says he will
soon submit to the town board.
Sylvia Willis isn't helping.
"The mayor," Daniel Willis says,
laughing bitterly. "Mayor in name only."
Staff writer Kristin Collins can be
reached at 829-4881 or kcollins@newsobserver.com.
|